замечания ( категория А )

A01

3.8.26 = 23.36.43

38(9 А)19 [ 18(14)33(20 a)29+ ; a (19)13+ ] (12)32
[ K.W.Kruijswijk , 3.7.17.26 = 23.27.28.36 ...19(9)23(12)22.32 ... ]
(17 B)27(31)21.27+.
А (13)33(8 C)28(12)22+.
B (18)31.13(14 DEFG.20)29(25)24+.
C (9)29(14)24+.
D (22.33)27(39)49+.
E (23.33)10(29)15(34)38(39)49+.
F (33)4(23)10(29)15(34)38(40)33.50+.
G (32)4(23)15(37 H)10+.
H (28)42+.


A02

6.20.35 = 34.43.44

29(11)23(24 A)18(29)13(34)8(16 B)3(340 C)21.49(21)16(40)11.50+.
A (17)18(21)13(27)9(31)4(37)15(40 D)31/26.48+.
B (340)2+.
C (21.340)21 [ 449+ ] +.
D (25)40.39+.


A03

8.10.14.20 = 17.28.29

11(12 А)6(19 B)283.1(24 CD)5.32(39)49+.
А (19)293(194)19.7(14)1 ZZ1(25)22(12)20.17/18+.
В (17)1(21)18(19 E)31 Z2(15 FG)26(23)25(32)48(38)24+.
С (17)6(21 H)33(27 I)38(31)24.36+.
D (33)5(24)23+.
E (15)283(25)24(140)9/4.16+.
F (25) 26(27)48(15)22.34(22 JK)39(27)23+.
G (26)37(15 L)283.25(31)48(36)37+. [ нет финала ; некомпозиционно ]
H (22)23+.
I (15)38(26 M)42(25)24+.
J (30)25(24)20(24)9(23)13(249 N)9/4(33)14(29)20(34)38(39 O)49+.
K (20)40(30 PQ)24+.
L (25)283.5(30)24+.
M (24) 20+.
N (28)30/35(32)24(37)47+.
O (40)33(45)50+.
P(22)44(204)20+.
Q (193)45+.
Z 2?(25)7(12.14)=.
Z1 22?(12.3)=.
Z2 36?(25 YY1) =.
Y (26?)41(15)283.25(31)48(36)37+.
Y1 (14?)282(25 Y2)17.27(20 Y3)21(18)27(193)4.15+.
Y2 (26?)17 [ 18+ ] (25)11/12(30)7/6/22(20)24 [ 4/22/18/27+ ] 22(24)1(31 Y4)25(37)14(42)37.36+.
Y3 (17?)49(22)44(27)23+.
Y4 (304?)44(31)39.26+.


A04

11.13.29.33 = 10.35.44

4(19)27(24 A)49(30)24.21/32 [ 27/43+ ] (25)49 [ 16+ ] (17 BC)43(22 D)49(28 E)43(30)25(38) 14(33 F)20+.
A (34)30 -В.Трофименко, чемпионат Украины 2012 г. -49(39 GH)33(30)29(35)44(16)49+.
B (16)43(30)25(38)48(21)44-39(27 IJ)26(32)31+.
C (30)39.16+.
D (30)25(38)3(22 K)9(28)14(33)20+.
E (30)39+.
F (32)37(43)39+.
G (16)39.8+.
H (30)39.16+.
I (43)26+.
J (26)37+.
K (21)26(43)39+.



A05

14.17.19.28 = 8.27.43

[ 17.19.20.28 = 8.27.38 J.Bastiaannet ] [ JB ]
[ A.Kuijken , KvD 1992. : 6.8.14.19.21.23 = 16.27.31.32.38.43 ... 26(28)17.32.161
(12.17) ... ]
38 Z (20)3(194)25(32)48(21)31(30)26(34 A )33(40)28(45)22.50+.
A (35)32(40)28(22)45.34(38)48+.
Z 3? (22)18(32)20(37)13.47(13) [ (12) = ] =.




A06

19.20.21.22 = 8.29.32

3(194 AB)26 Z.27.15+.
A (227)25.24.16+.
B (204)26 Z1.27 Z2 +.
Z 25? .28(38)26(42)14(47 Y) =.
Z1 20?(227)26.48(23)15(29 Y1)10(34)25(42) =.
Z2 8?(23 Y2)12(238) =.
Y (48?)37.37+.
Y1 (28?)10(33)5(39)334/30/25(42)37+.
Y2 (28 ?)38.47+.


A07

21.22.24.26 = 9.32.37

3(29 AB)20(34)28.16 [ F.Calzona , 1975 : 26.27.30 = 37.D40 ...49(34)16 ... ] (39 C)49+.
A (30)28 [ 8+ ] 31.35+.
B (22-27)12.31+.
C (40)11(45)50+.




A08

23.27.29.30 = 8.9.12

4(33 A a )36(38 B)3(42)47(48)42.25+.
A (304)36(33)3(40 b)18(45)38/42/47(50)33+.
B (34)3(339)22 ZZ1(43)27/13/9/4 [ это не дуаль , так как если 13(48) кроме 31 выигрывает и 24+ ] (48)31+.
Z 18?(43 Y) =.
Z1 13?(40 Y1)19.43(44 Y2) =.
Y (28)40(43)34(49)43+.
Y1 (28)22.44/50 +.
Y2 (45)39(50)6(45)1+.
a(32)15 Z2(294)24.2+.
b (38)14 Z3(29)32.22 +.
Z2 3(35)13(40 Y3)19.16(44 Y4) =.
Z3 13(40)19.42(44 Y5) =.
Y3 (28)22.24/20/15(40)33(45)50+.
Y4 (45)11(50)6(45)1+.
Y5 (45)33(50)6(45)1 +.


A09

3.15.17.29.34 = 7.13.48

1(22 A B)43(28)39.48(20 C)43(24 D)25 Z(32 E)14(38)139(43 F)5.48+.
A (20)43(24)39.48(29)25(21 A1 )13-9.26(33)21(39)49+. A1 (33)13-9 Z1.21(39)49+.
B (21)43(27)39.48(32)42(20)15(37)47+.
C (33)43(20)21(25 G)43(30 C1)25(38)48+. C1 (39)34+. [ C1 - поддавки ]
D (25)21(30)13-8.35(32 H)24(37)47+.
E (29)14(34)32(40 I)28(45)50+.
F (8)4(42/43)19.48/49+.
G (39)13-8.43/48+.
H (33)30(38)48+.
I (39)49+.
Z 49?(30 Y Y1)43(35)49(33)44(38)=.
Z1 43?(22)16(9)4(39)27(44)11/22(50)=.
Y (33?)43(29 Y2)25(38)8.3(18)9(23)14(33)43+.
Y1 (29?)40(293)1(9 Y3)4(38)23.10(24)15+.
Y2 (30)25(38)48+.
Y3 (8)2(32)34(37/38)24+.


A10

12.18.19.22.35 = 10.32.50

4(193)27.36(17 A)27(28 B)45(33)43(22)16(28)43(40 C.39)48.25(32)20(37)47+.
A (28)9(32 D)3(18)9(23)14(28)45(33)37(38 E)48+.
B (29)38(34)43(340)38(22 a )33(27)45(32.37)47+.
C (39)25(32)20(37)47+.
D (40)14(33)3(18)9(23)14(29)20(45)15(34)38(39)49+.
E (39)32(44)28(49 F)44.34+.
F (50)6(40.45)1+.
a (44.40)34+.
[ J. Burggraaff (De Gelderse Dammer, 6/1947) : 9.17.19.22.24.26.30 = 31.33.35.38.40.43.45 ...39.32.29.4.27(33)43 ...] [ AT ]


A11

12.18.22.24.28 = 9.34.42

3(23)26(32 A)12(27 VP1 BC)20(31)15(327 D)20.25.26+. VP1 (238)21(27)17(31)15…+.
A (33)29.38+.
B (37)20.25+.
C (38)15.349+.
D (38.37)339(42)20+.
[ J.van Kestern , Het Eindspel 1940 (1941) : 25.32 = 34.42.D50 ... 33(31 A)15(327 B)20.25.26 +. A (38)15.349 +. B (38)33(37)339(42)20 +. N.Tsomik , Шашки , 1983 : 21.23.24.32 = 34.42.D11 ... 7(26ABCD)20(31)15(38)33(37)339(42)20 +. A(30)25(26)29(31)34(38)33(37)23(42)239 +. B(37)20.25.16 +. C(38)15.349.16 +. D(239)23(38)33(30)19(27)14(31)10(37)5(42)34.48 + ;
J.Bastiaannet , Het Damspel , 1990 : 10.23.27.32 = 9.34.42 ; Г.Исаев , ч.Украины 1995 : 23.24.27.32 = 7.39.42 ] [ VM ]



A12

5.8.11.27.33.39 = 9.14.24

3(44 AB)40(39 C) 19(16 DEF)7 Z(10 GG1)5(43)29(21)42(48 VP1)194.16+. VP1 (49)38.16+.
A (13)19.10.30(38)48+.
B (16)34/30/25(38)48(21)9(26)4(10)15(31)26(43)48(49)43+.
C (38)10.19.43/49+.
D (17)7(10)5(43)12 Z1.13.49+.
E (43)10.49+.
F (10.43)29(48 F1)42.6+. F1 (49)38.6+.
G (21)10.16+. G1 (44)10.49+.
Z 1?(10.21)29(27 Y)42(32 Y1Y 1.1)=.
Z1 29?(22)194(27 Y2)=.
Y (26?)42(44)33+.
Y1 (44?)33(49)38+. Y 1.1 (43?)48(49)43+.
Y2 (28?)23.49+.


A13

5.36 = 20.23.33.40

[ В.В.Решетников : "Федоров Михаил Васильевич" , д.191, с.191 , 2008.: 5.19.22.28.32.38.39 = 15.25.26.29.30.31.40 ... 27(31)37.304.23 ... ]

15(41)29 Z(46 A a)10(19)35.24.24+.
A (10)4(46)23-18(23)34.18.18+. [некомпозиционно ]
a (47)24.24+.
Z 35?(47 Y)28(36) [ ( 41/42/38/24)= ] =
Y (46?)10 .. и как ..VP.


A14

14.27.31 = 12.25.42.43

8 Z(36 A)20Z1 z.3(41 B)37.9 Z2(31 VP1)36(30 C)31(34)48(40)38.45+.
VP1 (30)31(34)48(40)38.45+.
A (32)20.3(32-37 a)26.34+.
B (30)14(35 D)23(31 b)28(40) - H.J. v. Alphen 1956.– 43-39(45)39-33(50 E)42-37.6.47+.
C (37)47(30)39(35)34+.
D (34)39.38.46+.
E (41)46(50)42-37.26+.
Z 20? .8(30 Y Y1)3(35 Y2)12(32)45 Z3(36 Y3)39(38 Y4)33(41)23(47)=.
Z1 2?(32)20.19(38)32(41 Y5)2(30)35(47)=.
Z2 14?(30)41(35)39(40)36(32)41(38)47(43 Y6) =.
Z3 23(40)26(45)=.
Y (36?)3 - и дальше варианты VP/B/C/D/E.
Y1 (32?)3(32-37)26.34+.
Y2 (34?)12(39 Y7)34(32)21(32-37)3.25.26+.
Y3 (32-37?)50.36(40)22(45)50+.
Y4 (41?)38.46(40)28(45)50+.
Y5 (30?)35(41)2(47)16+.
Y6 (45?)33(50)6+.
Y7 (32)45(32-37)50.36+.
a (36)14(38)33(30)39(35)34+.
b (32)46(40)39(45)42-37/38/33+.
z 37? (31/32)= ; на (32)28(41)2(47)22(33) [ (41/36/29)= ] 18(29) [( 28/17/6/15/42/47) =] 18-13(23) [ (12/1/15/33/34/40/45)= ] =.



A15

19.20.31 = 12.30.39.50

8 Z (36)3(41 A)25(23 B C)3(47)26(36)24 Z1(9 D)48(27)37(38)19(20)24.39+.
A (25)24.14(34)30.44+.
B (47)20.24.39+.
C (46)3 Z2(24)19(5)14.39+.
D (47)12.29.39+.
Z 7?(37)25(204)1(42)50-45 z(30)34(24)30.1-34(40 Y1)=.
Z1 37? (18 Y2.34)=.
Z2 20? (19-23)42(32)30-24/25(49)20(44)34(49)30(35)25(29)=.
z 12(47 Y)=.
Y (30)34(48)12-29(26)30(48)39-34(26)42.25.34(23)29.44+.
Y1 (47)33.34+.
Y2 (29)24.31.39.34+.


A16

33.38.40 = 9.18.48.49

4(45 AB)493.43.50+.
A (39)493.43.35+. [ A = VP1 ]
B (42)37(45 CD)44 [ 32/15+ ] ZZ1(38 E)39(50)31(36)18-13+.
C (38)43 [ 12/10/15/18-13/4-9/4-13+ ] 32.45+.
D (39)43 [ 31/4-13/12/32/10/15+ ] 18-13.45+.
E (50)32.28+.
Z 32?(39 Y)28 [ ?? ; 10/27/9/4-13/15+ ] (44.34 )=.
Z1 43?(50)10(45) [ (44)= ] 23(50)45(44)=.
Y (50)44.28+.




A17

39.43.44 = 10.28.42.45

40.5(40 AA1B)38.35+.
A (48)28-23+. A1 (49)38+. [ A1 = VP1 ]
B (44)38.50+. [ B = VP2 ]
[ M. van Dijk , Dе Problemist , 1998 : 20.39.43 = 10.28.35.48 ...5(24 A)30.42 ... ; A (25)34...] [ AT ]


A18

8.9.37.40 = 19.33.38.39

[ Фрагмент. Б.Иванов , PWCP-2 (21), 2008. : 8.9.26.32.40.42 = 19.31.33.36.39.41 ...37.38.13 ... ]
13(18 A)32.2(45)11.6+.
A (19)34.4(41)10(47)15+.


A19

9.18.22.26.28 = 10.29.38.48

32 Z 5(31 A a)46(27 VP1)24 Z1(36)42(23BC)3(41)14(46 D)24-19(27-32)38 Z2 .5.49 +.
VP1 (36)42(27 b)24 и дальше VP +.
A (42)37(27)10(32 E)28(31)22.28(36 F)29-23(14)18(20)12(24)7(29)1(33) 39/50 (41)
22.46+.
B (32)3(41)37.14(38)9(23)14+.
C (31)24-19(22)23(28)26(41)42-37.42 Z4 +.
D (47)14-20(33)15.21/16+.
E (13)15(19 G)4(24 c)31/36.27(39)49+.
F (13)29-23(36)46(31 F1)32/28+. F1 (32)28+. [ F1 - поддавки / некомпозиционно ]
G (27-31)23(29 G1)47.8/2+. G1 (42)47.8/2+.
Z 5?(33)24.37(27)5-19 z(32 Y)28(31)13(23 Y1)4.36(38)27(42)4(48 Y2)=.
Z1 42?(23)3(32)14 Z3(31-37)31(38)10(43 Y3)26(49) =.
Z2 5?(46-37 Y5)31(38)19-14.49 =.
Z3 25(38)33(37)24(42 Y4) =.
Z4 31?(38) =.
Y (13?)2(32 y)28(23)19(31)8(37)26(41)3(47)19-14+.
Y1 (36?)4(23)19(41)10+.
Y2 (47?)15+.
Y3 (42?)26+.
Y4 (41?)14+.
Y5 (41?)38.19-14.49+.
a (27)46(27-31)24(13)20(36)15/42+ ; если 15(23)8/2(41)19(47)24.24 +.
b (28) 3/12 + ; если 3(41)37.20(37)23+.
c (18-23)18(24)12(32)28(30)7/8/18 +.
z 10(13)15(27-31 y1) =.
y (23)24-19/13.13 ...+.
y1 (23?)19(14)4(13-19)36(23)47...+.


A20

15.18.22.26.28 = 7.29.38.41

24 [ J.Bastiaannet , KvD 1992 , cat.B : 15.18.22.26.28 = 11.24.38.41 ...7 ... ] (32 A)
27.1(22 BCD )23(28)32(20 E )15(37)14.150(31)5.26+.
A (20)15(32)27.36(37)1(23)29(31.41)10(47)15(41)5+.
B (23)29(36)34.25.9+.
C (36)34.25.9+. [ C = B1 ]
D (20)40 [дуаль 40/45+ ] 36+.
E (37)5.24-19.37+.
[ забавное дополнение ИП откопал А.Полевой :
МК "Беларусь-2012" , категория С [39] W.Riemens : 11.15.18.21.22.26.28.39 = 29.30.36.37.41.42.48.49 с решением 483.294.43.38.7 ...]


A21

19.24.30.35.45 = 10.11.44.50

5(34 A)40.7(29 B)2(33)16(34-40)39.39(45)11(50)6+.
A (40)35(34.34)7(39)2(30.43)44(48)39+.
B (34-40)1.44.45+.



A22

3.12.22.32.39.45 = 6.13.42.50

1(37)48(41)37.25(28 A)8.44(50 B)3+.
A (27)139.31(38)48+.
B (38)40.7/1+.


A23

6.9.10.12.13.16 = 20.21.24.37

[ Фрагмент этюда М.Lepšić , minieindspelen , 2007 : 1.4.14.16 = 46.D33 ...24(10)15(19.24) J.Bus 18(30)41(21)37(6) H.J.van Alphen 7 (27)16 ...+. ]

15.4(19)7.16(31)26(34)16-21(40 A)17(45)261(50 B)16.7+.
A (39)49(11)261+.
B (11)6(50)217+.


A24

10.11.17.19.20.27 = 8.18.28.29

[ Фрагмент проблемы Е.Копылова , 4-й чемпионат Новополоцка ,2003 г. : 10.11.17.19.20.26.27.36 = 8.18.28.29.33.37.38 ....371.32.31.3 ...+ . ]

3(19-24 A)38.6+.
A (204)32.5+.




A25

15.16.18.26.29.34.40 = 8.20.27.45

21(17 AB)2.2x30x11.1+.
A (24)2(17 B)2x30x11.1+. [ A = VP ]
B (27)2.2x30x21.21+. [ B = A = VP1 ]

[ W.Lente , De Problemist , 1958 : 8.14.16.18.26.27.34.36 = 17.21.32.38.41.42.43.44.45 ...33.12.33...] [ AT ]